ALL CONFERENCE 2010-Current
GARDEN STATE ALL-CONFERENCE (GSAC)
ACADEMIC YEAR 2018-19
| SPORT | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Women Basketball | 2019-20 | Liana Martinez | First | Guard | Tracy Green |
| Men's Soccer | 2019 | Tomar Crawford | First | Defender | Giovanni Soto |
| Women's Cross Country | 2019 | Gabrielle Grant | 4th Place | Edgar Aguilar | |
| Women Cross Country | 2019 | Emma O'Brien | 8th Place | Edgar Aguilar | |
| Men's Cross Country | 2019 | Christopher Benitez | First | Champion | Edgar Aguilar |
| Men's Cross Country | 2019 | Ryan Scully | Second | Runner-up | Edgar Aguilar |
| Women's Volleyball | 2019 | Crystal Mudry | Second | Outside Hitter | Samoya Bailey |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2018-19
| SPORT | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Men's Soccer | 2018 | Victor Souza | Second | Mid-Fielder | Giovanni Soto |
| Women's Cross Country | 2018 | Tatiana Mehos | First | Deana Dedovitch | |
| Men's Cross Country | 2018 | Christopher Benitez | First | Deana Dedovitch | |
| Men's Cross Country | 2018 | Ryan Scully | Second | Deana Dedovitch | |
| Women's Volleyball | 2018 | Melaine Cuco | All-GSAC | Setter | Samoya Bailey |
| Women's Volleyball | 2018 | Samantha Frola | All-GSAC | Middle-Hitter | Samoya Bailey |
| Women's Basketball | 2018-19 | Liana Martinez | First | Point Guard | Tracy Green |
| Baseball | 2019 | Adrian Alarcon | Second | Outfielder | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2019 | Jason Romero | Second | Designated Hitter | Steven Mimms |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2017-18
| SPORT | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Men's Soccer | 2017 | Christiano Neves | First | Forward | Giovanni Soto |
| Men's Soccer | 2017 | Andre Sajnoski | Third | Forward | Giovanni Soto |
| Wrestling | 2007-18 | Anthony Romero | Second | 133 Lb. | Christoper DiSanto |
| Women's Cross Country | 2017 | Justine Conca | First | Champion | Deana Dedovitch |
| Women's Volleyball | 2017 | Estephany Nunez | Outside Hitter | Samantha Reed | |
| Women's Volleyball | 2017 | Misurela Liukovi | Libero | Samantha Reed | |
| Women's Basketball | 2017-18 | Cherie Smedile | Guard | Tracy Green | |
| Women's Basketball | 2017-18 | Grace D'Annibale | Guard | Tracy Green |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2016-17
| SPORT | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Men's Soccer | 2016 | Ahmed Aboudonia | First | Defense | Fredy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2016 | Dave Herrera | Second | Foward | Fredy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2016 | Brahyan Tabares | Third | Midfielder | Fredy Herrera |
| Men's Cross Country | 2016 | Christopher Loughman | First | Fifth Place | Deana Dedovitch |
| Men's Cross Country | 2016 | Andy Jaipersaud | Second | Ninth Place | Deana Dedovitch |
| Men's Cross Country | 2016 | Daniel Silver | Second | Tenth Place | Deana Dedovitch |
| Women's Cross Country | 2016 | Justine Conca | First | Champion | Deana Dedovitch |
| Women's Cross Country | 2016 | Amanda Duran | Second | Seventh Place | Deana Dedovitch |
| Women's Soccer | 2016 | Alessandra Wojcicki | Third | Goalkeeper | Jolynn Di Ienno |
| Women's Volleyball | 2016 | Francela Ulate | First | Outside Hitter | Samantha Reed |
| Women's Volleyball | 2016 | Gioia Abreu | Second | Right Side | Samantha Reed |
| Women's Volleyball | 2016 | Ariel Frazee | Second | Middle Hitter | Samantha Reed |
| Women's Basketball | 2017 | Cherie Smedile | First | Guard | Tracy Green |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2015-2016
| SPORTS | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Baseball | 2016 | Junior Nasi | First | Infielder | Steven Mimms |
| Men's Basketball | 15-16 | McKay LeDuke | First | Forward | Bobbie Morgan |
| Men's Basketball | 15-16 | Doug Palmadessa | Third | Guard | Bobbie Morgan |
| Men's Soccer | 2015 | Malik Stewart | First | Forward | Freddy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2015 | Paul Nganansou | First | Defender | Freddy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2015 | Nikola Nikoloski | Second | Mid-Fielder | Freddy Herrera |
| Women's Volleyball | 2015 | Nadia Vaso | First | Setter | Helene Liaci |
| Women's Volleyball | 2015 | Gioia Abreu | First | Outside Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Women's Volleyball | 2015 | Rhonyelle Sowell | Second | Middle Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Men's Cross Country | 2015 | Connor McGillick | Second | Top 5-10 | Deana Dedovitch |
| Men's Cross Country | 2015 | Aneudy Nunez | Second | Top 5-10 | Deana Dedovitch |
| Women's Cross Country | 2015 | Yanibel | First | Top 1-5 | Deana Dedovitch |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2014-2015
| SPORTS | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Baseball | 2015 | Blake Smith | First | Pitcher | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2015 | Junior Nasi | First | Infielder | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2015 | James Fitzgerald | First | Outfielder | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2015 | Andujar Cedeno | Second | Designated Hitter | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2015 | Wifredo Otero | Second | Catcher | Steven Mimms |
| Men's Basketball | 2015 | Doug Palmadessa | First | Guard | Carlos Quinteros/Pete Jablonski |
| Men's Basketball | 2015 | Louis Isern | Third | Forward | Carlos Quinteros/Pete Jablonski |
| Men's Soccer | 2015 | Kevin Campos | First | Forward | Fredy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2015 | Nikola Nikoloski | Second | Mid-Fielder | Fredy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2015 | Santiago Rivera | Third | Forward | Fredy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2015 | Jamal Salifu | Third | Mid-Fielder | Fredy Herrera |
| Women's Soccer | 2015 | Nicole Van Dyke | Second | Mid-Fielder | Jolynn Di Ienno |
| Softball | 2015 | Linzi Reginald | Second | Pitcher | Mallorie Gilbride |
| Volleyball | 2015 | Nadia Vaso | First | Setter | Helene Liaci |
| Volleyball | 2015 | Kimberly Watson | First | Outside Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Volleyball | 2015 | Taylor Martin | Second | Outside Hitter | Helene Liaci |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2013-2014
| SPORTS | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Baseball | 2014 | Matthew Dawkins | Second | Outfielder | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2014 | James Donohue | Second | Infielder | Steven Mimms |
| Men's Basketball | 2014 | Ruben Acosta | Second | Guard | Carlos Quinteros |
| Women's Basketball | 2014 | Mary Haines | Second | Center | Tracy Green |
| Men's Soccer | 2013 | Santiago Rivera | First | Forward | Fredy Herrera |
| Men's Soccer | 2013 | Jonathan Maher | Second | Defender | Fredy Herrera |
| Women's Soccer | 2013 | Sara Ramirez | First | Forward | Mallorie Gilbride |
| Volleyball | 2013 | Marissa Lortz | First | Middle-Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Men's Tennis | 2014 | Ezio Cecere | First | Fourth Singles | Sal Guillen |
| Men's Tennis | 2014 | Eric Sapiro/Kyle Fligel | First | Second Doubles | Sal Guillen |
| Men's Tennis | 2014 | Abdelkader Sardena | Second | Fifth Singles | Sal Guillen |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2012-2013
| SPORTS | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Baseball | 2013 | Joey Mazzo | Second | Infielder | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2013 | Anthony Martinez | Third | Infielder | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2013 | Tom Felice | Third | Outfielder | Steven Mimms |
| Men's Basketball | 2013 | Larry Burroughs | First | Forward | Matt Odalen |
| Men's Basketball | 2013 | Ricky Carroll | Second | Guard | Matt Odalen |
| Women's Basketball | 2013 | Felicia Castillo | Third | Forward | Tracy Green |
| Men's Soccer | 2012 | Reinaldo O. Sanchez | First | Forward | Cristian Raigoza |
| Men's Soccer | 2012 | Nicholas Duarte | Third | Mid-Fielder | Cristian Raigoza |
| Women's Soccer | 2012 | Joanna Tarkazikis | Second | Forward | Colleen Caldwell |
| Women's Soccer | 2012 | Aya Saleh | Second | Mid-Fielder | Colleen Caldwell |
| Women's Soccer | 2012 | Natalie Valdivida | Third | Mid-Fielder | Colleen Caldwell |
| Softball | 2013 | Rebecca Carlone | Second | Infielder | Mallorie Gilbride |
| Softball | 2013 | Sarah Stofan | Second | Outfielder | Mallorie Gilbride |
| Softball | 2013 | Lauren Hozak | Second | Pitcher | Mallorie Gilbride |
| Softball | 2013 | Marissa Varon | Second | Catcher | Mallorie Gilbride |
| Volleyball | 2012 | Kimloi Clark | First | Outside Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Volleyball | 2012 | Marissa Lortz | First | Middle-Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Men's Tennis | 2013 | Jiabo He | First | Fourth Singles | Sal Guillen |
| Men's Tennis | 2013 | Richard Mills | First | Sixith Singles | Sal Guillen |
| Men's Tennis | 2013 | Ezio Cecere/Carlos Munoz | First | Second Doubles | Sal Guillen |
| Men's Tennis | 2013 | Eric Sapiro/Daniel Winters | First | Third Doubles | Sal Guillen |
ACADEMIC YEAR 2011-2012
| SPORTS | YEAR | NAME | TEAM | POSITION | COACH |
| Baseball | 2012 | Mike Brito | First | Infielder | Steven Miimms |
| Baseball | 2012 | Kevin Catherina | First | Outfielder | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2012 | Joey Mazzo | Second | Designated Hitter | Steven Mimms |
| Baseball | 2012 | Mike Rizzo | Second | Infielder | Steven Mimms |
| Men's Basketball | 2012 | Ricky Carroll | Second | Guard | Matt Odalen |
| Men's Soccer | 2011 | Jonathan Aisoni | First | Mid-Fielder | Cristian Raigoza |
| Men's Soccer | 2011 | Juliano Luz | Second | Goalie | Cristian Raigoza |
| Men's Soccer | 2011 | Sebastian Ramirez | Second | Defender | Cristian Raigoza |
| Women's Soccer | 2011 | Christine Villanueva | First | Mid-Fielder | Ralf Embro |
| Women's Soccer | 2011 | Lauren Kozlowski | First | Goalie | Ralf Embro |
| Women's Soccer | 2011 | Lindsey Root | Second | Defender | Ralf Embro |
| Women's Soccer | 2011 | Kristina Cordova | Second | Forward | Ralf Embro |
| Softball | 2012 | Alexa Klapach | Second | Infielder | Rebecca Dodd |
| Softball | 2012 | Trish Kirwan | Second | Ourtfielder | Rebecca Dodd |
| Softball | 2012 | Jenna Meny | Second | Pitcher | Rebecca Dodd |
| Volleyball | 2011 | Haley Dukes | First | Middle-Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Volleyball | 2011 | Jackie Cruz | First | Outside Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Volleyball | 2011 | Gladis Oseguera | Second | Outside Hitter | Helene Liaci |
| Golf | 2012 | Young Eom Han | Second | Tom McGovern |